Columbia Arcadia II (women’s) review: the best-value first rain jacket
Everyone needs a rain jacket, and your first one should not cost a fortune or feel like a garbage bag. The Columbia Women’s Arcadia II is the answer most women land on — a waterproof, breathable, packable shell with a proper adjustable hood, at a price that leaves plenty in the budget for the rest of your kit.
The verdict
The best-value first rain jacket. The Arcadia II pairs Columbia’s Omni-Tech waterproof-breathable membrane with fully sealed seams, an adjustable storm hood, zippered hand pockets, and a drawcord hem — a genuinely capable shell for everyday rain, one of the most popular women’s rain jackets sold. It has no pit zips, so it vents less than a hiking-specific shell on hard climbs, and it is a shell only with no insulation. But for commuting, travel, dog walks, and casual hikes in the rain, it is hard to beat for the money.
What it does
A rain shell’s job is to keep rain and wind out while letting some of your body’s moisture escape, and the Arcadia II does it with Columbia’s Omni-Tech membrane and fully sealed seams — the taped seams being what separates a real rain jacket from a water-resistant one. It adds the features that make a shell livable: an adjustable, attached hood that actually stays up in wind, zippered hand pockets, elastic cuffs, and a drawcord hem to seal out drafts, and it stuffs down to travel easily in a bag. It is the outer layer of the three-part system — a base layer against the skin, an insulating layer for warmth, and this shell on top when it rains or blows. See how to dress for the bush for the full picture.
What verified buyers say
With thousands of ratings, owners are consistent about the value:
- Keeps you dry. The core praise: it genuinely sheds rain, with a hood that works in wind.
- Light and packable. Buyers stuff it in a bag for travel and commuting and forget it is there until they need it.
- Great price and colors. The recurring verdict: an excellent everyday rain jacket for the money, in lots of color options.
- Sizing and layering. Several size up to layer a fleece underneath; the cut is on the trimmer side.
Worth knowing
Know its limits. There are no pit zips, so on a hard, sweaty climb it vents less than a hiking-focused shell and you can feel clammy inside — opening the front and pockets helps, but for high-output hiking a vented jacket is more comfortable. Like all coated shells it can eventually wet out in a long, hard downpour and benefits from an occasional DWR refresh. And it is a shell with no insulation — layer it over warmth in the cold. For everyday and casual-hike rain, none of that gets in the way.
Who it is for
This is for a woman who wants an affordable, dependable rain jacket for daily life, travel, and casual hikes. If you hike hard in weather and want underarm venting and a more breathable fabric, step up to the Marmot PreCip Eco; if you face sustained mountain storms and want a bombproof, fully vented Gore-Tex shell, go to the Outdoor Research Aspire 3L. Layer it over a fleece and base layer, and see how to dress for the bush.
Specs at a glance
Type: 2-layer waterproof-breathable shell · Membrane: Omni-Tech, sealed seams · Hood: adjustable, attached; drawcord hem · Venting: none (no pit zips); fit runs trim · Best for: everyday & casual-hike rain
The Verdict
The Columbia Arcadia II is the rain jacket to start with: genuinely waterproof, packable, hooded, and cheap, and one of the most popular women’s shells for good reason. Size up if you plan to layer under it. Hiking hard and want venting? Step up to the Marmot PreCip Eco. Facing real mountain storms? Go to the Outdoor Research Aspire 3L.
Wilderness Experts is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. It never changes what we recommend.
